​​​

Proposed Revision Request Detail Help
PRR Life Cycle*********Closed
PRR Details
PRR #
1254
Title Variable Energy Resources Off Peak Opportunity Outage
Date Submitted 5/12/2020 12:57 PM
PRR Category B
Priority Normal
Owner Aditya Chauhan (SCE) (Southern California Edison)
Status Closed
Status End Date 10/20/2020 11:59 PM
Related BPM Outage Management
BPM Section 11.1.3
RSS Subscribe
Existing Language
 

11.1.3                Off-Peak Opportunity RA Maintenance Outage

ISO Tariff Section 9.3.1.3.3.3

An Off-Peak Opportunity RA Maintenance Outage may be approved by the ISO to be initiated and completed during off-peak hours without RA Substitute Capacity for the resource adequacy capacity on the outage. 

A request for an Off-Peak Opportunity RA Maintenance Outage must meet the following conditions:

Outage must be submitted to the CAISO no more than forty-five days prior to the first day of the resource adequacy month for which the outage is requested and no less than eight days prior to the start date for the outage

1.        Schedule the outage to begin during off-peak hours on a weekday, and to be completed prior to on-peak hours the following weekday, or to begin during off-peak hours on Friday, or on Saturday, Sunday, or a holiday, and to be completed prior to on-peak hours  on the next weekday.,

The ISO will consider requests for an Off-Peak Opportunity RA Maintenance Outage in the order the requests were received. 

If the ISO Outage Coordination denies a request for an Off-Peak Opportunity RA Maintenance Outage for failing to meet the requirements in Section 9.3.1.3.3.3(c)(2), the Scheduling

Coordinator for the Resource Adequacy Resource may request an RA Maintenance Outage with Substitution or may request that the ISO accommodate the outage at another time.  

To the extent that an approved Off-Peak Opportunity RA Maintenance Outage is not completed during off-peak hours as scheduled, and extends into on-peak hours, the Scheduling Coordinator for the resource must submit the portion of the outage that extends into on-peak hours as a new Forced Outage.

 

Off Peak Hours

Weekday hours from HE 23 to HE 06 and all day Saturdays, Sundays, and WECC holidays.

a.        New Year’s Day

b.        Martin Luther King Day

c.        President’s Day

d.        Good Friday

e.        Memorial Day

f.         Independence Day

g.        Labor Day

h.        Veteran’s Day

i.          Thanksgiving Day

j.          Friday after Thanksgiving

k.        Christmas Eve

l.          Christmas Day

Proposed Language
 

Variable Energy Resources

 

Outage must be submitted to the CAISO no more than forty-five days prior to the first day of the resource adequacy month for which the outage is requested and no less than eight days prior to the start date for the outage

Schedule the outage to begin during off-peak hours on a weekday, and to be completed prior to on-peak hours the following weekday, or to begin during off-peak hours on Friday, or on Saturday, Sunday, or a holiday, and to be completed prior to on-peak hours  on the next weekday.

VER resources may schedule outages after the normal daily generating hours, during non-generating periods.  Outage must end by 05:59hrs.

Reason For Revision
 

The current POSO requirement is not aligned correctly for Solar VER resources and creates instances of Solar VERs being subject to POSO, strictly as a result of a calculation due to an outage submittal. The status of the solar resource after production hours has no impact on reliability as the resource could not generate once the sun goes down or "after production hours".

Currently, at 10pm, VERs can request an “Off Peak Opportunity Outage (OPOO)” that requires the resource’s return to service by 5:59 AM, the following day. A solar VER cannot produce during these hours. In spite of that, if the SC is short RA, the resource may get a Planned Outage Substitution Obligation (POSO). In order to mitigate superfluous POSO requirements, the creation of a "VER Off Peak Opportunity" selection on outage submittals would eliminate the inessential POSO once selected for Solar Resources (VER) performing overnight maintenance. The CAISO’s VER forecast itself will validate that the use of "VER Off Peak Opportunity" outage is correctly applied.

Click here to view the Recommendation Details for this PRR
BPM PRR Submitter

Aditya Chauhan (SCE) (Southern California Edison)
Modified BPM language proposed by the PBM Chnage Management Coordinator

Identification of the authorship of comments

Action

Approve the BPM PRR as modified.

The times during which the CAISO allows Off Peak Opportunity outages are based on its definition of peak vs. off-peak hours and applies across all technology types.  The CAISO does not find it appropriate to create a separate definition of peak hours that applies specifically to solar resources.  Other resource types also face recurring patterns of unavailability.  For example, a conditionally available resource that faces noise limitations could argue that it should be allowed to take an Off Peak Opportunity outage as soon as its noise permit prevents operation even if that is before the CAISO’s standard off-peak hours begin.  Additionally, it is not feasible at present to create such a solar-specific definition of off-peak hours.  Doing so would require the CAISO to track the sunrise and sunset times particular to each solar resource.
Statement of apparent requirements of the BPM PRR

Priority and rank for any BPM PRR requiring a CAISO system change

Proposed effective date(s) of the BPM PRR

Other recommended actions

Having recommendation comment period for stakeholders to submit comments about the rejection.
Click here to view the Final Decision for this PRR
Final Decision

CAISO will use it's recommended language for posting.
Stakeholder Comment

None

Effective Date

11/1/2020
Action

Adopt the recommendation as modified

Announcements
PRR 1254 has been taken off of hold and placed in the recommendation comment period again. Comment period will be open until September 16, 2020 to align with the next comment period date.
Posted On - 8/21/2020 11:10 AM
PRR 1254 has been placed on hold until a final decision can be completed.
Posted On - 8/6/2020 7:42 AM
PRR 1254 has been made available at this time to allow additional time to review and submit comments. 
Comment period will close 6/16/2020.  PRR will be discussed during the June and July BPM meetings.
Posted On - 5/18/2020 10:47 AM
Impact Analysis
Impact Analysis not available.
Initial Comments
No Initial Comments available for this PRR.
Recommendation Comments
The ISO recommends following addition to the OM BPM point 2 of section 11.1.3:

2. Schedule the outage to begin during off-peak hours on a weekday, and to be completed prior to on-peak hours the following weekday, or to begin during off-peak hours on Friday, or on Saturday, Sunday, or a holiday, and to be completed prior to on-peak hours on the next weekday. Outages scheduled for Solar PV resources to follow the timings below:

a. November (date of DST switch) – March (day prior to DST change) - after 6pm PPT
b. March (date of DST switch) - November (day prior to DST change) – after 8pm PPT with below exceptions;
i. (Except May 1 – August 31) – after 9pm PPT
8/21/2020 11:22 AM
Logged By - Abhyankar, Kalyani (CAISO)
Late comments received from Aditya Chauhan from SCE on 7/20/2020. Late comment attached.
7/20/2020 3:07 PM
Logged By - Hines, Nicole (CAISO)
Please see attached for PG&E's PRR 1254 comments.
7/14/2020 11:31 AM
Logged By - Mark Tiemens (PG&E)
Click here to view the Appeals for this PRR
Click on the '+' icon to submit a New Appeal

# of Appeals In Progress - 0
# of Appeals Closed - 0
# of Appeals Abandoned - 0
There are no Appeals on this PRR.
Attachments